Saturday, January 3, 2015

Technical Details

As we've mentioned our prop shaft broke just short of our destination last weekend.

We were about 5 miles north of Daytona Beach and heard a loud pop and lost power. We quickly got the anchor down and I went below into the engine compartment to investigate. I found the prop shaft broken right by the coupling.

After we got hauled we were able to really review the issue. Apparently the previous owner had challenges with the shaft coming out of the coupling. I'm guessing that because of the prop he installed that was massively over-pitched the force of the prop would pull the shaft out of the coupling. To remedy that someone drilled through the shaft and installed a 3/8" bolt to hold it in place. I totally missed this issue as did our surveyor and the yard at Oxford. It's pretty obvious the previous owner knew of this and the risk. By drilling through a 1.25" shaft with 3/8"the strength was reduced to 7/16". It's no wonder that under the stress of 3000 rpm the shaft eventually broke.

We are lucky that it didn't happen when we were 100 mi. offshore or when navigating some of the challenging channels we've been in. Fortunately we were in a mild current with water deep enough to anchor but shallow enough that had we sunk we would have been on the bottom with about a foot or so of water in the keel doing little or no damage.

During the entire trip we have had an issue with the bilge pump cycling on and we were unable to find any source of water incursion but water has been coming in through the shaft log since shortly after we left Oxford.

This past Tuesday we removed the shaft and drive assembly and hopefully will be able to get the replacement parts early this week. The shaft log will need to be epoxied in to seal it and then I can put some paint on the bottom and prop after we return from the cold.

Then we can be launched and the engine realigned.

The actual parts replacement are the shaft, engine coupling and we are replacing the cutlass bearing while it is out.

We have some other work to do while we're waiting for the parts so the time isn't wasted. Eventually when we get all the work done there will be beach days or time to just kick back in the cockpit on anchor with a nice rum drink.

Meanwhile the weather has been warmer than up north and Daytona is a nice town. The yard so far has been great and I feel comfortable with the work being done. The damage done by the previous owner is just another example of how some owners do really stupid stuff that they don't understand and emphasizes the need to do all work competently and check everything thoroughly.

6 comments:

  1. Hi guys! Sorry to hear about your trials and tribulations with the shaft. As you said - good thing it didn't happen in a more inconvenient and/or dangerous situation. Are you also replacing the prop back to a more normal-sized one? Also, best of luck with the sea trials, and hopefully the potential buyers are serious and worthy of her.

    Cheers, and stay warm...oh, right...nevermind. :-)

    Nico
    S/V Bedouin

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Nico,

    Things went well with our sea trial although we were a bit anxious about starting the engine and genset in below freezing temps. We worked to start the engines the day before the sea trial so once in the water they started easily. The buyers have accepted the boat and we expect to close by the end of this week. Quite a surprise to sell the boat over the holidays.

    We are considering making prop changes. According to everything from the manufacturer it is the right size but it may still need to be pitched down a bit. Still not satisfied that we have identified the actual cause of the failure. It is possible the roots were in an incident before we bought the boat and it just took time to mature.

    We are certainly happy to be back in warmer weather after our week in frosty. Hopefully now we can put our cold weather clothes away.

    Maris

    ReplyDelete
  3. Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info. lära sig teknisk analys

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow, cool post. I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article... but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. teknisk analys aktier

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow, cool post. I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article... but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. teknisk analys aktier

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the comments. Glad you enjoy the Blog.

    ReplyDelete